The Man in the Picture!
Storyline: A group of hunters go out looking for game. One of the men (a skeptic) is told not to enter a section of woods known as the Haunted Forest but he refuses. As he enters the forest, he is attacked by American Indians who plan on burning him alive after binding him to a stake. He is rescued by their noble chief, Chief Manyfingers, so named because he has six fingers on each hand. The man wakes up and believes he dreamed the whole ordeal, until back at the lodge he sees a painting of Chief Manyfingers with an image of him tied to a stake behind him!
Credits: